Supreme Court finds dismissal unlawful due to use of investigator to monitor job performance

| Author: Tony Imossi (Secretariat) | Filed under: General News
Supreme Court finds dismissal unlawful due to use of investigator to monitor job performance

In its 11 June 2018 decision (15094/18) the Supreme Court found that a dismissal for just cause is unlawful if the employer uses an investigator to monitor an employee's job performance. The ban on the use of investigative agencies also applies to activities carried out by employees off their employer's premises and renders investigative reports unusable unless they concern behaviour that suggests criminal activity.

The Rome Court of Appeal overturned a Tribunal of Rome decision and found that investigative reports may be used in court, as in the case under review, the employee performed the majority of their role outside the company premises. As a result, the court found that the employer could use an investigator to monitor the employee's job performance.

The employee challenged this decision in the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court cited the Workers' Statute (Law 300/70), which allows employers to use an investigative agency to:

protect company assets; or
monitor job performance and potential breaches of contract.
However, for the Supreme Court, employee monitoring by security guards or investigative agencies cannot under any circumstances concern the fulfilment of an employee's contractual obligations.

The ban on the covert monitoring of an employee's job performance also applies to activities performed off company premises without prejudice to the use of a private investigator to check potentially criminal behaviour.

The Supreme Court rejected the Rome Court of Appeal's decision that employers can use investigative agencies to monitor the job performance of employees under any circumstances.

For further information on this topic please contact Andrea Stanchi at Stanchi Studio Legale by telephone (+39 02 546 9522) or email (

The materials contained on this website are for general information purposes only and are subject to the disclaimer.

ILO is a premium online legal update service for major companies and law firms worldwide. In-house corporate counsel and other users of legal services, as well as law firm partners, qualify for a free subscription.

Source: ilo

Working with the Law Society

The ABI is the only association in this industry to be recognised by the Law Society of England and Wales, and included in the Law Society of Scotland's approved Supplier Scheme.

The highest independent professional bodies for solicitors put their trust in us. We’re confident you can do the same.

The ABI other partners also recognise the value of affiliation to the principal professional body in the investigation and litigation support sector:

COURTSDESK SEARCHER is an on-demand search for court cases, or parties involved in court cases, in England and Wales and the Republic of Ireland.
Scotland Law Society logo
Professional Indemnity Insurance
Thank you, your message has been sent.
A member of our team will be in touch shortly.